Fall review roundup #2: Macbeth, The Cut, American Buffalo, Goodnight Desdemona, Pippin and more

The fall season kicks into gear with productions by Crow’s, Canadian Stage, Coal Mine and a handful of smart indie companies

Fall review roundup #2: Macbeth, The Cut, American Buffalo, Goodnight Desdemona, Pippin and more
Evan Buliung plays an unnamed man drawn by an AI chatbot into the world of Shakespeare’s Macbeth. Photo by Elana Emer

November continues to be jam-packed with theatre, so I’m going to try to keep most of these brief. You can find my first review roundup here, and I’ll likely post a third one this time next week. As always, be sure to check out my listings to see when productions are closing (many have been extended), as well as what’s coming up in December and January.

Classics, revisited

Ted Dykstra (left) and Shawn Doyle do some sleuthing in must-see revival of American Buffalo. Photo by Elana Emer

You can find my reviews of two modern classics — American Buffalo (Rating: ✭✭✭✭) and Goodnight Desdemona (Good Morning Juliet) (Rating: ✭✭✭) — over at The Toronto Star.

✅ = Critic’s pick / ✭✭✭✭✭ = outstanding, among best of the year / ✭✭✭✭ = excellent / ✭✭✭ = recommended / ✭✭ or ✭ = didn’t work for me

I liked the latter, especially with playwright Ann-Marie MacDonald getting to play lead character Constance Ledbelly, whose academic theories get tested when she enters the worlds of Othello and Romeo and Juliet. MacDonald, best known as a novelist these days, is a captivating, energetic performer, and the fact that she’s in her 60s now adds to the pathos of the play; Constance has been buried in books for decades before venturing out on her big adventure. And while the play doesn’t have the pizzazz or metatheatrical novelty it must have when it debuted in 1988, it’s still lots of fun, particularly for Shakespeare lovers. The show continues to Nov. 22. Ticket details here.

I also loved Jordan Laffrenier’s gritty production of the David Mamet play for Coal Mine Theatre, which reminded me of the company’s inaugural production of The Motherfucker with the Hat twelve years ago. I can’t remember the last time I saw Shawn Doyle — who’s getting lots of buzz for the Newfoundland-set Netflix thriller Below — on a Toronto stage. But he’s perfect as Don, the proud, quietly simmering owner of a Chicago junk shop who believes he may have been underpaid by a coin collector and schemes to get it back — via his friends Bob (Mackenzie Wojcik) and Teach (Ted Dykstra) — by robbing the guy. The must-see show continues to Dec. 6. Ticket details here.

🎟️
See what else is currently playing in So Sumi’s Toronto Theatre Listings

✅Macbeth (Crow’s Theatre)

We’ve seen different takes on Shakespeare’s Macbeth before, obviously, including solo versions — among them Rick Miller’s** unforgettable MacHomer. But this new Crow’s Theatre solo staging (Rating: ✭✭✭✭) co-created by actor Evan Buliung and director Christopher Manousos is among the first to approach it from an AI perspective.

**Did you know that Miller is playing Oscar Wilde in select performances of De Profundis? I absolutely loved Damien Atkins’ Dora-winning performance, but I’d also really like to see Miller, a fantastic actor who we rarely get to see perform in other people’s works. The Soulpepper schedule outlines when he’s on. The show runs until the end of the month.

✅ = Critic’s pick / ✭✭✭✭✭ = outstanding, among best of the year / ✭✭✭✭ = excellent / ✭✭✭ = recommended / ✭✭ or ✭ = didn’t work for me

Buliung plays an embittered man who’s angry about not advancing much in his career. Entering a sort of high-tech chamber, he consults with a chatbot, who suggests he explore the world of Macbeth. And so, after a few queries (“What’s a thane?” he asks), he immerses himself in the text, playing most of the characters, with the AI voice, enhanced by some flashing lights, standing in for the witches as well as a narrator dispensing basic stage directions.

The setup could be smoother; it’s not really clear who Buliung’s unnamed protagonist is, what field he works in and what’s at stake for him. (Manousos established the parameters of his recent Measure for Measure in this same space with much more clarity.)

But once he begins telling the story of vaulting ambition and how violence begets more violence, it becomes a mesmerizing examination of guilt and culpability and (possibly) how AI can influence those with mental illness.

Besides playing the title character, Buliung takes care to differentiate the others, giving Banquo more of a Scottish accent, donning old-fashioned spectacles to play Malcolm and lending his King Duncan a bit of an older man’s gravitas and stoop. His Lady Macbeth, who gets the news of her husband’s promotions as a voice message (which in a clever touch she rewinds a bit to fully grasp its meaning), seems disturbed from the start, continually touching her face with her hands.

I was surprised that this pared-down version of the play (there’s no mention of Birnam Wood, for instance) includes the post-regicide porter scene, adding a much-needed comic break from the intensity before and after.

Evan Buliung, photographed by Elana Emer

Some of Manousos’ staging is highly effective. In Scott Penner’s set, three dark chairs on a raised circular platform might suggest the three witches at first (the wired sisters, perhaps?), but when they’re brought down and positioned outwards, they could be sentries guarding Duncan’s room. In the banquet scene, one chair is left in the middle of the platform where Banquo’s ghost appears, as indicated by a green light in Chris Malkowski’s design and a sting from Thomas Ryder Payne’s incredible sound design.

Manousos and Buliung do a lot to fill out the world of the play; when Duncan arrives at the Macbeths’, the way he’s led by Lady M betrays her impatience. Later, after the banquet scene, she tries to placate the guests (us in the audience, seated on opposite sides of the narrow Crow’s Studio space). Pay attention to how Buliung-as-Lady-Macbeth uses his hands here and elsewhere, all foreshadowing her sleepwalking scene.

No doubt the creators are drawing on horrific recent stories about AI chatbots contributing to people’s suicides, turning this production into a cautionary tale. If there were more care about setting up Buliung’s disturbed, desperate man at the beginning of the show, it might land with more force.

Macbeth continues at Crow’s Theatre’s Studio (345 Carlaw) until Dec. 6. Ticket details here

🎟️
See what else is currently playing in So Sumi’s Toronto Theatre Listings
Hallie Seline and Wade Bogert-O’Brien play a couple who disagree about whether their son should be circumcised. Photo by Kayla Gordon

✅The Cut (Harold Green Jewish Theatre Co.)

Expectant parents Sarah (Hallie Seline) and Andrew (Wade Bogert-O’Brien) are forced to confront big issues about faith, family, trust and their sense of community and belonging in The Cut (Rating: ✭✭✭✭), Jordi Mand’s two-hander that deserves productions throughout North America.

✅ = Critic’s pick / ✭✭✭✭✭ = outstanding, among best of the year / ✭✭✭✭ = excellent / ✭✭✭ = recommended / ✭✭ or ✭ = didn’t work for me

Sarah is Jewish, Andrew is not. Years earlier, the two agreed that if they ever had a son, they would not circumcise him. But now that they’re close to the delivery date, Sarah has changed her mind. Andrew discovers this when he finds an article titled “Why Circumcision is the Only Option” in a box in the nursery room they’re attempting to decorate.

As with Mand’s other play for The Harold Green Jewish Theatre Co., 2004’s In Seven Days, the characters are so richly drawn that the issues emerge naturally and don’t feel grafted on.

We get a good sense of Sarah’s relationship with her parents, and learn about how they reacted negatively to the fact that she was marrying outside their faith. We also hear about Andrew’s high maintenance mother and his brother, as well as his recent diagnosis of multiple sclerosis, and how that has affected his feelings of isolation and physical vulnerability.

Under director Brendan McMurtry-Howlett, the one-act play moves swiftly in Shauna Jones’ single-room set, with the two actors doing lots of tasks as they hash things out.

Bogert-O’Brien and Seline are completely convincing in their shifting dynamics and heightened interactions, when a stubborn attempt to use a carpet cleaner can distract them from the fear of the unknown.

One especially powerful moment comes when Sarah says she’s grieving the life she had growing up — something relatable to anyone who’s had to navigate different cultures and beliefs in a relationship.

The ending is appropriately ambiguous and open-ended, and will likely prompt lots of post-show discussions, just as In Seven Days (which is being adapted for film) did two years ago.

The Cut continues at the Greenwin Theatre, Meridian Arts Centre (5040 Yonge) until Nov. 22. Ticket details here

🎟️
See what else is currently playing in So Sumi’s Toronto Theatre Listings

Indie productions, in brief

Photo by Elana Emer

A solid Defence

With the ongoing rape case at Cornell, Liliana Padilla’s How to Defend Yourself (Rating: ✭✭✭✭), produced by Icarus Theatre, couldn’t feel timelier or more urgent. After a female college student has been sexually assaulted by two fraternity brothers, a group of her peers meets to learn defence skills but also how to communicate desire and consent. Each student arrives with a particular background and reason for being there, which is evident in the script but also suggested through smart casting and direction by Emily Anne Corcoran. (Corcoran designed the set as well, outfitted to look like a gym, complete with white interlocking tiles, which intriguingly come apart through the course of the play.)

✅ = Critic’s pick / ✭✭✭✭✭ = outstanding, among best of the year / ✭✭✭✭ = excellent / ✭✭✭ = recommended / ✭✭ or ✭ = didn’t work for me

It takes a while to get to know the students, many of whom, as outlined in the script, carry on conversations simultaneously. But they reveal themselves the way real people do; what they say isn’t always what they feel. The result, complete with evocative fight scenes (coordinated by Cara Rebecca), is a frank look at sex, consent and the body that doesn’t pull its punches. To Nov. 28 at the Theatre Centre BMO Studio (1115 Queen West). Ticket details here

Katherine Cappellaci and Ziye Hu become new home owners — at a cost — in Radiant Vermin. Photo by Juniper Simpson Serrano

Home truths

Although written more than a decade ago, Philip Ridley’s Radiant Vermin (Rating: ✭✭✭✭), produced by Riot King, will resonate with anyone who’s been shut out of the insane housing market. Expectant couple Jill (Katherine Cappellacci) and Ollie (Ziye Hu) are offered a rundown home in an iffy neighbourhood by one Miss Dee (Lisa Horner) — can you guess what the “D” stands for? They don’t have the money to renovate, but that’s quickly solved when they figure out a way to deal with unwanted intruders — a.k.a. human vermin. And before long their neighbourhood is gentrified.

Sebastian Biasucci directs this darkly satiric morality tale with lots of style and efficiency in the tiny Red Sandcastle space, with the actors easily navigating the cramped playing area, complete with washroom. (Amelia Mielke-O’Grady designed the clever set.) While one scene late in the play goes on a bit too long, the script is full of clever twists and turns, which the actors play with relish. To Nov. 22 at the Red Sandcastle Theatre (922 Queen East). Ticket details here

Photo by Valentina Caballero

Pippin pops

There’s something appropriate about the terrific young musical theatre company Bowtie Productions mounting Pippin (Rating: ✭✭✭✭), a show that’s all about finding one’s direction in life. In the Middle Ages, Pippin (Anthony Palermo), the newly-graduated son of King Charlemagne (W. Joseph Matheson), encounters war, experiments with sex, tastes power and tries out domesticity, all of which leave him unfulfilled. Stephen Schwartz and Roger O. Hirson’s musical (with additional material by Bob Fosse) is both a counterculture commentary and a look at the seductive power of entertainment.

Olivia Daniels’ production, while obviously limited by its budget, feels fresh and bursting with imagination. She gets solid performances by her cast, with Palermo, KC Martinez (as the Leading Player), Donna Garner (Berthe) and Daniele Bauer (Fastrada) stand-outs, lively choreography by Meredith Shedden that obviously tips its hat to Fosse but still feels new and a full band (led by Jo O’Leary-Ponzo) that occasionally drowns out the singers.

There are flaws in the material, including a wandering narrative and sometimes annoying self-consciousness. But this production accepts them, embraces them and plows through, with lots of razzle dazzle and loads of talent. Until Nov. 21 at the Factory Mainspace (125 Bathurst). Ticket details here